According to an exclusive report on NYC Newswire, after more than two decades serving the Clinton Hill community, Connecticut Muffin will serve its final cup of coffee on Saturday, November 29, 2025. The café—located at the busy corner of Myrtle Avenue and Clinton Avenue—has been a neighborhood fixture since opening in 2003. But a significant rent hike has made staying open impossible.
Rent Spike Forces Shutdown
Employees told NYC Newswire that the landlord plans to increase the rent by an additional $4,000 per month, pushing the already expensive lease beyond what the business can manage. The café’s departure removes one of the area’s most reliable gathering spots, known for its steady service and comforting atmosphere.
A Daily Stop for Thousands
For years, Connecticut Muffin has provided the essentials of Clinton Hill’s morning routine—coffee, cappuccinos, lattes, fresh muffins, and warm croissants. Students from Pratt, local families, and longtime residents relied on the café as a welcoming space to start their day or settle in with a pastry and a book. Its consistency and familiarity made it a cherished part of the neighborhood fabric.
Staff Relocating to Other Brooklyn Shops
Although the Clinton Hill location is closing, customers will still be able to find many of the same employees at other Connecticut Muffin outposts:
-
Park Slope: 423 7th Avenue, Brooklyn, NY
-
Ditmas Park: 1106 Cortelyou Road, Brooklyn, NY
Regulars hoping to stay connected with their favorite baristas will be able to visit them at these locations.
Residents React With Disappointment
News of the closure has hit many in the community hard. One loyal customer shared their feelings with NYC Newswire:
“I’m really going to miss this place. It’s my go-to spot at least 4 days per week. There are other coffee shops around but none like Connecticut Muffin. The staff has always been pleasant and the products have always been consistent. It’s a shame that we continue to lose great neighborhood spots because of high rents.”
A Cornerstone of Clinton Hill Says Goodbye
The final day on November 29 is expected to draw a stream of longtime patrons who want one more chance to stop by, grab their usual order, and say farewell. Connecticut Muffin’s closing marks the end of an era for Clinton Hill and adds to growing concerns about the survival of independent businesses facing soaring commercial rents.
Subscribe to the ClintonHill.com Newsletter for constant updates on Clinton Hill news, development, eating & drinking, politics, store openings, store closings, events and more.
